The validation of the greenlight 300 to the International Protocol by Graves et al from the Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation, Rochester, was published in the journal Blood Pressure Monitoring in early 2004.
It was reported that the objective of the study undertaken was ‘to determine whether the greenlight 300 is an accurate replacement for the mercury sphygmomanometer in auscultatory blood pressure measurement using passage of the International Protocol as a valid test of device performance’ 1.
The International Protocol2 was published in 2002 in an aim to update and simplify previous protocols for evaluating the accuracy of blood pressure measurement devices without sacrificing their integrity.
The validation procedure detailed in the International Protocol is carried out in two phases, allowing elimination of very inaccurate devices at an early stage in the procedure. Phase 1 requires the recruitment of 15 subjects, with phase 2 requiring a further 18 (33 in total). Subjects are selected to fulfill the criteria set out in the protocol. These include specifications regarding sex, age and blood pressure range.
A number of blood pressure measurements taken with the device being tested are compared with a standard mercury sphygmomanometer. The results from the validation of the greenlight 300 to the International Protocol are shown below.
| Within 5mmHg | Within 10mmHg | Within
15mmHg |
Result | |
| Requirement to pass (1 of 3): | 25/45 | 35/45 | 40/45 | |
| SBP | 40/45 | 44/45 | 45/45 | Pass |
| DBP | 31/45 | 40/45 | 44/45 | Pass |
| Within 5mmHg | Within 10mmHg | Within
15mmHg |
Result | ||
|
65/99 | 80/99 | 95/99 | ||
|
60/99 | 75/99 | 90/99 | ||
| SBP | 84/99 | 95/99 | 98/99 | Pass | |
| DBP | 74/99 | 90/99 | 96/99 | Pass |
| 2/3 readings within 5mmHg | 3/3 readings >5mmHg | Result |
||
|
22/33 | ≤3 | ||
| SBP | 33/33 | 0 | Pass | |
| DBP | 27/33 | 3 | Pass |
The greenlight 300 passed all phases of the International Protocol validation procedure. It was concluded in the paper by Graves et al that this demonstrated that the greenlight 300 provides accuracy comparable to the mercury sphygmomanometer in auscultatory blood pressure measurement and that it is the first device to fulfill the AHA experts’ quest for a reliable replacement for the mercury manometer in auscultatory blood pressure measurement1.
The full ESH International Protocol for validation of blood pressure measuring devices in adults can be accessed from the guidelines section of the ESH website.
The paper by Graves et al detailing the validation of the greenlight
300 to the International Protocol can accessed online from the
Blood Pressure
Monitoring website
2. O’Brien E et al. Working Group on Blood Pressure Monitoring of the European Society of Hypertension International Protocol for validation of blood pressure measuring devices in adults. Blood Pressure Monitoring 2002;7:3-17



